Solvent Efficiency in Phytochemical Extraction: A Comparative Study of Methanol and Water in Cassia siamea

This study investigates the comparative solvent efficiency of methanol and water in the extraction of phytochemical constituents from the leaves and stem bark of Cassia siamea, a widely recognized medicinal plant used in traditional healing practices across Sierra Leone. As natural product research continues to garner global attention particularly in response to rising antimicrobial resistance and the search for safer alternatives to synthetic drugs there is an increasing demand for rigorous, evidence-based approaches to herbal drug development. Phytochemical extraction forms a foundational step in this process, with solvent selection playing a critical role in determining the yield, diversity, and concentration of bioactive compounds. Using a cold maceration technique, powdered plant materials were extracted separately with methanol and distilled water under standardized laboratory conditions. The resultant crude extracts underwent qualitative phytochemical screening to detect the presence or absence of key secondary metabolites, including alkaloids, flavonoids, tannins, glycosides, saponins, steroids, phenols, anthraquinones, and terpenoids, following protocols established by Harborne and Sofowora. The results demonstrated that methanol was significantly more effective than water in extracting a broader and richer spectrum of phytochemicals. Notably, methanol extracts revealed a strong presence of phenols, glycosides, and steroids, all of which are known to possess potent pharmacological properties such as antimicrobial, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and cytoprotective effects. In contrast, aqueous extracts were limited in their phytochemical diversity, detecting fewer compounds and showing reduced intensity for most metabolites. While water remains the solvent of choice in many traditional herbal preparations due to its safety and accessibility, these findings indicate that its extraction efficiency is relatively restricted, particularly for nonpolar or moderately polar compounds. The absence of phenols and steroids in aqueous extracts is particularly noteworthy, as it underscores the importance of using more polar organic solvents like methanol when aiming to capture the full phytochemical potential of plant material. This study not only validates the traditional medicinal relevance of Cassia siamea in Sierra Leone but also emphasizes the need for evidence-based optimization of extraction protocols in herbal pharmacognosy. The data presented herein contribute to the scientific foundation necessary for future work involving quantitative assays, bioactive compound isolation, pharmacodynamic studies, and eventually, the development of plant-based therapeutics. As the pharmaceutical industry increasingly turns to nature for novel drug leads, studies such as this are essential in bridging the gap between traditional knowledge and modern scientific innovation.